NWAMotherlode — Where Moms Click

Drama for Mama: American Idol

No matter how you feel about Neil Diamond’s music, you’ve got to hand it to the guy. He’s enjoyed one of the longest, most successful careers in music history. The legend mentored five finalists on American Idol Tuesday night when each singer performed two songs.

Jason Castro’s first song was “Forever in Blue Jeans.” It was okay, but just okay. Simon called it “forgettable.”

David Cook followed with “I’m Alive,” a lesser known song. Neil Diamond said it gave him goose bumps. Hard to get a much better review than that.

Brooke White sang “I’m a Believer,” and I didn’t love it. Simon called it a “nightmare.” It wasn’t that bad, but it definitely wasn’t great.

David Archuleta sang “Sweet Caroline.” Neil Diamond called him a prodigy. Randy called him “da bomb.”

Syesha wrapped up the first round of songs with “Hello Again.” Has anybody noticed how beautiful this girl’s teeth are? They’re perfect. Oh, and she can sing, too.

On to Round Two: Jason was back with “September Morn.” Here’s his problem. He’s so laid back that he almost seems a little bored. The judges were not impressed.

David Cook brings what Jason lacks – raw intensity. Cook sang “All I Really Need Is You,” and it sounded like something you’d hear on the radio today. Randy said he “rocked the house” and Simon called it “brilliant.” The big shocker came when Paula, who is typically very non-committal when it comes to predictions, said “I feel like I’m already looking at the American Idol.” Wow.

Brooke White redeemed herself with her piano version of “I Am I Said.” When she does what she does best, she really shines.

Boy wonder David Archuleta sang “America” for his second song, a choice that the judges said was very smart. (Nobody ever gets eliminated after singing a patriotic song. Ever notice that?)

Syesha closed the show with “Thank the Lord for the Nighttime.” She really seems to be hitting her stride these days and looks more comfortable on stage than ever. Randy said “You are finally realizing who you are, and you’re in the zone.”

Prediction: If voters go by performance and not popularity, Jason will go home. If it’s a popularity vote, Brooke and/or Syesha will be in the bottom two.